Find your dream home in the beautiful Hudson Valley

1174 Potter Mountain Road, Gilboa, NY 12076

$2,995,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 5 Baths: 5 Square Footage: 6,242 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 1,612,156 Status: Active
Current Price: $2,995,000 List Date: 2/18/2026 Last Modified: 2/18/2026

Description

An early 19th Century Greek Revival Church, reimagined into a stunning residence on thirty-seven acres of rolling fields, woods and trails at the foothills of the Catskill Mountains. Inside, the c1837 timber frame structure's main living space has soaring ceilings and exposed hand hewn beams. The floors are white oak, and windows line the lime-washed walls floor-to-ceiling. A library is perched in the cupola with gorgeous custom bookshelves, and under the stairwell you'll find a 600+ bottle wine room, temperature controlled and accessed through steel doors. A gas fireplace grounds the large seating area, which looks into the open chef's kitchen. The space is fabulous for entertaining. In the kitchen there is a 48'' AGA induction range, a large center island, and the walk-in pantry houses a second sink and expertly hides the paneled refrigerator. The primary suite has a wing of its own. It is big and bright and like the rest of the house it looks out onto the dramatic mountain view. The primary bath has a large wet room with two showers and a soaking tub, the hardware is beautiful, heavy unlacquered brass. In the opposite wing are two spacious guest rooms, a bunk room with four sweet & custom built-in bunks, and an incredible full bath with a double vanity and radiant heat. A home office space is perched on the third floor with a separate staircase, it is nicely and intentionally tucked in for privacy and quiet. The house is built into the hillside, the lower level is light filled and walk-out and there you'll find a family/media room, a wet bar, and a gorgeous laundry room with two washer/dryers, a farmhouse sink and lots of storage. Outside, you're completely immersed in nature with nearly forty acres to explore. Find streams and waterfalls, trails wind through the woods. Potter Mountain is a fabulous retreat for those wanting peace and quiet, but you're also close to hiking, farm-to-table dining, and Windham Mountain Club is right down the road. Just over 2h to NYC, a furniture package is available.

More Information MLS# 20260645

Contract Information

Listing Agreement: Exclusive Right To Sell Owner Name: Marquardt Occupant Type: Owner Lease Considered YN: No Current Price: $2,995,000 Original List Price: 2995000 List Price: $2,995,000 Status: Active Listing Contract Date: 2026-02-17 Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence

Location, Tax, and Legal

911 Address: 1174 Potter Mountain Rd Township: Other School District: Gilboa General Tax: 4705.31 School Tax: 3502.25 Tax Annual Amount: 8207 Tax Year: 2025 Assessors Full Market Value: 453750 Tax Assessed Value: 435600 Tax Legal Description: 1 Parcel Number: 204.-3-7.3 Tax Lot: 1 Tax Block: 1 Tax Exemptions YN: No Zoning: 1 Directions: Exit 20 off 87N. Continue on NY-32 N. Take NY-145 N to Potter Mountain Rd in Gilboa.

General Property Information

Rooms Total: 18 Bathrooms Half: 1 Above Grade Finished Area: 6242 Below Grade Finished Area: 0 Lot Size Acres: 37.01 Association YN: No Accessibility Features YN: No New Construction YN: No Garage YN: Yes Attached Garage YN: Yes Garage Spaces: 2 Waterfront YN: No Flood Plain YN: Unknown Senior Community YN: No Sign On Property YN: Yes Basement YN: Yes Stories: 3 Fireplace YN: Yes Fireplaces Total: 1 Wood Stove YN: No Spa YN: No List Price/SqFt: 479.81 Bedrooms Total: 5 Bathrooms Total: 5 Bathrooms Full: 4 Living Area: 6242 Year Built: 1837

Remarks and Miscellaneous

Public Remarks: An early 19th Century Greek Revival Church, reimagined into a stunning residence on thirty-seven acres of rolling fields, woods and trails at the foothills of the Catskill Mountains. Inside, the c1837 timber frame structure's main living space has soaring ceilings and exposed hand hewn beams. The floors are white oak, and windows line the lime-washed walls floor-to-ceiling. A library is perched in the cupola with gorgeous custom bookshelves, and under the stairwell you'll find a 600+ bottle wine room, temperature controlled and accessed through steel doors. A gas fireplace grounds the large seating area, which looks into the open chef's kitchen. The space is fabulous for entertaining. In the kitchen there is a 48'' AGA induction range, a large center island, and the walk-in pantry houses a second sink and expertly hides the paneled refrigerator. The primary suite has a wing of its own. It is big and bright and like the rest of the house it looks out onto the dramatic mountain view. The primary bath has a large wet room with two showers and a soaking tub, the hardware is beautiful, heavy unlacquered brass. In the opposite wing are two spacious guest rooms, a bunk room with four sweet & custom built-in bunks, and an incredible full bath with a double vanity and radiant heat. A home office space is perched on the third floor with a separate staircase, it is nicely and intentionally tucked in for privacy and quiet. The house is built into the hillside, the lower level is light filled and walk-out and there you'll find a family/media room, a wet bar, and a gorgeous laundry room with two washer/dryers, a farmhouse sink and lots of storage. Outside, you're completely immersed in nature with nearly forty acres to explore. Find streams and waterfalls, trails wind through the woods. Potter Mountain is a fabulous retreat for those wanting peace and quiet, but you're also close to hiking, farm-to-table dining, and Windham Mountain Club is right down the road. Just over 2h to NYC, a furniture package is available.

Status Change Information

Status Change Timestamp: 2026-02-17 Major Change Timestamp: 2026-02-18T00:23:06Z Major Change Type: New Listing

Appliances

Dishwasher: 1 Dryer: 1 Oven: 1 Range: 1 Refrigerator: 1 Washer: 1

Architectural Style

Other: 1

Attic Features

None: 1

Basement

Full: 1 Walk-Out Access: 1

Book Information

Liber/Book: 1 Page: 1 Section: 1

Construction Materials

Frame: 1 Wood Siding: 1

Cooling

Central Air: 1

Electric

200+ Amp Service: 1

Exterior Features

Private Yard: 1

Fireplace Features

Free Standing: 1 Gas: 1 Living Room: 1

Flooring

Hardwood: 1

Foundation Details

Concrete Perimeter: 1

Heating

Central: 1 Propane: 1

Interior Features

Beamed Ceilings: 1 Cathedral Ceiling(s): 1 Kitchen Island: 1 Pantry: 1 Wet Bar: 1

Laundry Features

Laundry Room: 1 Sink: 1

Levels

Three Or More: 1

Lot Features

Secluded: 1 Views: 1 Wooded: 1

Parking Features

Garage Faces Front: 1

Possession

Close Of Escrow: 1

Roof

Metal: 1 Shingle: 1 Wood: 1

Sewer

Septic Tank: 1

Structure Type

House: 1

Utilities

Electricity Connected: 1

View

Mountain(s): 1 Rural: 1 Trees/Woods: 1

Water Source

Well: 1

Window Features

Triple Pane Windows: 1

Showing Requirements

Appointment Only: 1 Call Listing Agent: 1

Location Tax and Legal

Street Number: 1174 Street Name: Potter Mountain Street Suffix: Road County: Schoharie State: NY Zip Code: 12076 Town (Taxable): Gilboa

Property Features

Appliances: Dishwasher; Dryer; Oven; Range; Refrigerator; Washer Architectural Style: Other Attic Features: None Basement: Full; Walk-Out Access Construction Materials: Frame; Wood Siding Cooling: Central Air Electric: 200+ Amp Service Exterior Features: Private Yard Fireplace Features: Free Standing; Gas; Living Room Flooring: Hardwood Foundation Details: Concrete Perimeter Heating: Central; Propane Interior Features: Beamed Ceilings; Cathedral Ceiling(s); Kitchen Island; Pantry; Wet Bar Laundry Features: Laundry Room; Sink Levels: Three Or More Lot Features: Secluded; Views; Wooded Parking Features: Garage Faces Front Possession: Close Of Escrow Roof: Metal; Shingle; Wood Sewer: Septic Tank Structure Type: House Utilities: Electricity Connected View: Mountain(s); Rural; Trees/Woods Water Source: Well Window Features: Triple Pane Windows Showing Requirements: Appointment Only; Call Listing Agent
Listing Courtesy of Four Seasons Sotheby's Int.
Listing Agent: Annabel Taylor
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.