5327 New York 212, Mount Tremper, NY 12457 (MLS# 20262736)

5327 New York 212, Mount Tremper, NY 12457

$1,300,000

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 5 Baths: 5 Square Footage: 3,300 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 146,362 Status: Active

Current Price: $1,300,000 List Date: 5/27/2026 Last Modified: 5/27/2026

Overview

Description

The Pines | Mt Tremper, New York A rare chance to steward one of the Catskills' most storied properties has quietly arrived. The Pines -- a cherished roadside inn and restaurant nestled between Woodstock and Phoenicia -- is ready for its next chapter. With more than five decades as a beloved Italian restaurant followed by a decade-long reinvention as a community gathering place, The Pines carries the kind of lived-in warmth that simply cannot be manufactured. What's on offer here isn't just a property -- it's a place people return to. Set on 3.36 acres, the grounds balance openness and intimacy: rolling fields, pockets of woodland, and direct waterfront access to the Beaverkill Creek. The main building operates as a functioning roadside lodge, with five upstairs suites -- two with en suite baths and three sharing a beautifully appointed common bath -- alongside a full kitchen, dining area, and a living room that invites lingering. A covered porch extends the experience outdoor ... (Read more) The Pines | Mt Tremper, New York A rare chance to steward one of the Catskills' most storied properties has quietly arrived. The Pines -- a cherished roadside inn and restaurant nestled between Woodstock and Phoenicia -- is ready for its next chapter. With more than five decades as a beloved Italian restaurant followed by a decade-long reinvention as a community gathering place, The Pines carries the kind of lived-in warmth that simply cannot be manufactured. What's on offer here isn't just a property -- it's a place people return to. Set on 3.36 acres, the grounds balance openness and intimacy: rolling fields, pockets of woodland, and direct waterfront access to the Beaverkill Creek. The main building operates as a functioning roadside lodge, with five upstairs suites -- two with en suite baths and three sharing a beautifully appointed common bath -- alongside a full kitchen, dining area, and a living room that invites lingering. A covered porch extends the experience outdoors, offering guests a quiet perch to settle into the rhythms of the surrounding landscape across the warmer months. The layout accommodates both nightly room rentals and full-property buyouts for groups seeking something more private. The restaurant wing is equally well-considered: a custom bar with dedicated seating, two dining halls, two full bathrooms, and generous storage throughout. The kitchen has been outfitted for serious culinary output, featuring an expansive commercial range with an oversized hood, walk-in refrigeration, multiple wash stations, and ample storage. A second structure on the property -- known affectionately as the Dog House -- arrives with its own bar setup and a separate liquor license. The property has hosted events, live entertainment, and more, opening the door to programming well beyond traditional food and beverage. A third building, currently leased to a commercial tenant on a month-to-month basis, provides immediate income from day one. Mechanical systems across the property have been substantially updated. A full list of improvements is available upon request. What The Pines offers its next owner is something increasingly rare: genuine optionality. Acquire it as a turnkey operation and build upon decades of goodwill and community devotion. You can acquire its strong social media following and marketing plans offering a smooth transition into ownership, reimagine it entirely as a bold new hospitality concept or withdraw it from the market altogether and craft something deeply personal -- a private compound unlike anything else in the region. The path forward is yours to define. Come see what's possible.

Listing Details MLS# 20262736

General Property Information

Bedrooms Total: 5
Rooms Total: 16
Bathrooms Total: 5
Bathrooms Full: 5
Above Grade Finished Area: 3300
Below Grade Finished Area: 300
Living Area: 3300
New Construction YN: No
Year Built: 1860
Garage YN: No
Lot Size Acres: 3.36
Flood Plain YN: No
Waterfront YN: Yes
Water Body Name: Beaver Kill
Basement YN: Yes
Stories: 2
Fireplace YN: No
Wood Stove YN: No
Sign On Property YN: No
Disclaimer: Buyers and Buyers' Agents should complete full due diligence on property and confirm all information is accurate, including but not limited to: taxes, acreage, permitting, etc.
List Price/SqFt: 393.94
Bathrooms Half: 0

Property Features

Architectural Style: Farmhouse Basement: Unfinished; Walk-Out Access

Contract Information

Original List Price: 1300000
Listing Contract Date: 2026-05-26
Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence
Listing Agreement: Exclusive Right To Sell
Owner Name: Bernstarr LLC
Occupant Type: Owner
Occupant Name: The Pines
Lease Considered YN: No

Location Tax and Legal

Street Number: 5327
Street Name: New York 212
County: Ulster
State: NY
Zip Code: 12457
Town (Taxable): Shandaken

Remarks and Miscellaneous

Public Remarks: The Pines | Mt Tremper, New York A rare chance to steward one of the Catskills' most storied properties has quietly arrived. The Pines -- a cherished roadside inn and restaurant nestled between Woodstock and Phoenicia -- is ready for its next chapter. With more than five decades as a beloved Italian restaurant followed by a decade-long reinvention as a community gathering place, The Pines carries the kind of lived-in warmth that simply cannot be manufactured. What's on offer here isn't just a property -- it's a place people return to. Set on 3.36 acres, the grounds balance openness and intimacy: rolling fields, pockets of woodland, and direct waterfront access to the Beaverkill Creek. The main building operates as a functioning roadside lodge, with five upstairs suites -- two with en suite baths and three sharing a beautifully appointed common bath -- alongside a full kitchen, dining area, and a living room that invites lingering. A covered porch extends the experience outdoors, offering guests a quiet perch to settle into the rhythms of the surrounding landscape across the warmer months. The layout accommodates both nightly room rentals and full-property buyouts for groups seeking something more private. The restaurant wing is equally well-considered: a custom bar with dedicated seating, two dining halls, two full bathrooms, and generous storage throughout. The kitchen has been outfitted for serious culinary output, featuring an expansive commercial range with an oversized hood, walk-in refrigeration, multiple wash stations, and ample storage. A second structure on the property -- known affectionately as the Dog House -- arrives with its own bar setup and a separate liquor license. The property has hosted events, live entertainment, and more, opening the door to programming well beyond traditional food and beverage. A third building, currently leased to a commercial tenant on a month-to-month basis, provides immediate income from day one. Mechanical systems across the property have been substantially updated. A full list of improvements is available upon request. What The Pines offers its next owner is something increasingly rare: genuine optionality. Acquire it as a turnkey operation and build upon decades of goodwill and community devotion. You can acquire its strong social media following and marketing plans offering a smooth transition into ownership, reimagine it entirely as a bold new hospitality concept or withdraw it from the market altogether and craft something deeply personal -- a private compound unlike anything else in the region. The path forward is yours to define. Come see what's possible.

Status Change Information

Major Change Timestamp: 2026-05-27T13:45:38Z
Major Change Type: New Listing
Status Change Timestamp: 2026-05-27

More Information

Book Information

Liber/Book: Yes
Page: 22
Section: 25.11

Location, Tax, and Legal

911 Address: 5327 NY 212 Mt Tremper, NY
Township: Shandaken
School District: Onteora Central School District
General Tax: 2397
School Tax: 2849
Tax Annual Amount: 5246
Tax Year: 2026
Assessors Full Market Value: 392857
Tax Assessed Value: 55000
Tax Legal Description: 25.11-1-22.200
Parcel Number: 25.11-1-22.200
Tax Lot: 22
Tax Block: Yes
Tax Exemptions YN: No
Zoning: R1.5
Directions: From Kingston: Take NY 28 West towards Pine Hill Right Turn onto NY 212 towards Woodstock Right turn into 5327 NY 212

Architectural Style

Farmhouse: Yes

Basement

Unfinished: Yes
Walk-Out Access: Yes

Listing Courtesy of BHHS HUDSON VALLEY PROP-WDST

Listing Agent: Quinn Hagstrand

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.